Rugby Football Cricket
Bulls Jomo Cosmos AB de Villiers
Cheetahs Kaizer Chiefs Titans
Griquas Orlando Pirates Cape Cobras
Sharks Rugby Sundowns Golf
WP Rugby SuperSport United Nedbank Challenge
The Stormers Other SS Golf Shootout
Phumelela
Premier Soccer League
SA Rugby
Sports Trust
Sunshine Tour
Kenyan Premier League
FA Zambia
 
International
 
Home Rugby Cricket Football Golf Motorsport Cycling Tennis Athletics Aquatics Boxing Schools Climbing Xtra
FootballUnderstanding the football brain... Part 2
25 January 2010 (09:52)
The brain says no to irrelevant training

Running for running's sake, as practised in the ‘bits and pieces’ approach, does not activate the football brain as the exercise has no football-specific content and structure. Physical trainers and coaches who still believe that pieces of general, non-football-specific training, particularly of athletic and power nature, can produce effects beneficial to the game, may have to de-train themselves and rebuild their expertise based on new scientific premises.

One scientific discovery concludes that the gains resulting from simple non-specific training do not transfer to complex game sports. The cause of this is that the sport-specific brain is ‘tuned’ according to the specifics and complexity of that particular sport. To transfer the effects of general exercise to complex activities, the brain needs to be ‘rewired’ with new circuits.

This could take very long time and effort, though such transfers could only partially materialise. We are yet to witness the speed of a world class sprinter being reproduced in football, basketball or handball. Still, many footballers are made to believe that they can be much faster in the game through general/athletic speed training. Many hours of training and hopes are wasted on this illusion.

Genetic and environmental influences interact to continually influence the brain. In competitive football the most important influences are coming from the training environment, controlled by coaches. For the training process to achieve the objectives of players’ development and maximum performance it is imperative that the work prioritises mental functions and activities in relation to aspects of technique, tactics and physical conditioning and not the other way around.

We need to view the brain as a muscle that can be strengthened or weakened. Experiences, actions, thoughts and emotions play a decisive role by continually stimulating the brain, thus strengthening it. Without sustained activation and stimulation, mental activities remain weak or deteriorate. We are learning to see mental weaknesses as physical abilities in need of practice. An unfit football brain translates into inferior performance and that always is an indication of a wrong training concept where priorities are upside-down.

The prerequisite is to ensure that from the first to the last minute of practise the football brain is continuously activated and stimulated. Every exercise and training activity must contain a large variety of football-specific mental challenges. Studying players’ reactions in training, it has been recorded that mental stimulation is ‘lost’ every time when:

o the content and/or exercise structure is irrelevant,
o the tasks are already familiar or too easy,
o there is excessive explanation and/or demonstration,
o there is no variety of exercises,
o the work involves the body, not the mind,
o outdated routines are introduced as new ideas and
o abusive language, swearing is used for verbal punishment.

The power of brain stimulation

Probably the most significant and exciting contribution for optimising performance is the advanced concept and structures of training that are based on game-related exercise, match simulations and conditioned small games. This type of training is superior due to its ‘built in’ football brain stimulation, from the warm-up to the end of the workout.

During exercise every player’s step or movement interacts with various specific mental processes -- concentration, decision making, emotion-control, improvisation/creativity, self-evaluation, communication and so on. As this specific training continuously reflects the constructive, compelling and unlimited diversity of the game. It also carries over massive positive and arousing feelings that enhance players’ work attitude, motivation and mood.

These intricate mental processes and reactions are the subject of several studies in neuroscience. Some of the findings are news of exceptional significance. For instance, mounting evidence shows that the same brain systems that coordinate movement in the game also coordinate tactical thinking, deal with emotions, movement memory and learning. This leads to an immensely valuable conclusion regarding the content of training. It certifies, among other facts, that football-specific work with, or in relation to the ball, is crucial to every brain function that is associated to football. As we see it, this interacting between movement and brain strongly suggests that improvements in the football brain’s functions depend on practising specific movement.

Rewarding satisfaction

Neurologists produced another striking finding, which involves the effects generated by specific movement, particularly aerobic work, on activating and stimulating attention, concentration, positive thinking, motivation, control over emotions and stress. Here the key discovery came from identifying essential brain chemicals –- the dopamine system -- responsible for constructive actions, enthusiastic and creative attitude, rewarding satisfaction and pleasure, which are released by the brain under the effects of aerobic exercise that is also mentally engaging. Certainly, this is big news for the promoters of ‘new wisdom’!

Experiments done with a large variety of aerobic ball work structures -- such as warm-up, technique training, endurance, intricate movement, related abilities, power-leg and specific speed of reaction -- produced unparalleled benefits. The dynamic synergy between diverse football-specific tasks and simultaneous involvement of the football brain resulted in massive improvement, not only to the players’ playing ability but, equally important, in maximising commitment, motivation, concentration, creativity, enthusiasm and effort recovery.

To discuss the complete list of positive effects and reactions would by far exceed the purpose of this article. Although we do not yet see any significant influence in global football from the latest neuroscience discoveries, there is proof that at the level of the world’s best clubs, mainly from Spain and Brazil, more and more time is allocated in training to intense, ball integrated work, which has ‘built-in’ mental stimulation.

Maximising development

In South Africa, the ‘new wisdom’ concept of total brain-and-ball football specificity was introduced at the high performance youth programme of Sundowns’ development team in November 2008. Before defining the content and methods of training, careful consideration was given to the characteristics of players and environment (this is a prerequisite of ‘Maximal Training’). After only ten months of activity it became evident that the players’ progress had surpassed all expectations, by a large margin.

The most impressive improvements were recorded in the competency, diversity and creativity of applying the technique, tactical mobility (regardless positions) and remarkable initiative. A process of accelerated development took place and consequently the 18-year-old Siyanda Xulu and his colleague Siyabonga Ngubane are now playing in the first team with resounding success. Several other development players from the same programme have topped current PSL technical standards and are ready to move up to professional football.

It is hard to believe that these youngsters, who impress so much in their capacity to sustain the highest demands on fitness, never took a single lap of plain running during their new training programme. They display the mentality of ‘spectacular football, the South African way’ and this was attested to by the organisers of the World Under-18 Club Championship in May 2009, who, after assessing all 18 participating teams’ performances, concluded that ‘the South African team -- Sundowns -- played the best quality football of the tournament’. All these are just a few of the extraordinary merits and benefits of maximising the football brain!

The environment can reshape the football brain

The lesson on the role of environment in the development of players, performance and in the evolution of the game in general, has not yet been learned. Coaching literature and syllabuses compiled for coaching qualification only vaguely and speculatively touch on this vastly influential factor.

Despite growing evidence that should convince us that the continual interacting between genes and the environment determine changes in the brain, very little information, if any, has reached coaching theories and practice. Ignoring knowledge on how to monitor and deal with uncontrolled environmental and social influences could have a devastating effect on players’ upbringing and performance.

Most of a player’s football qualities take shape through interaction of many genes, as influenced by various components of the environment, such as the national/regional general sport and football policies and mentality, training, climate, geography, social-economic factors and so on. Complete acceptance should be given to the reality that environment has the power to change brain structures, for better or worse.

The phenomenal dominance of Kenyans and Ethiopians in mid and long distance running was attributed, some years ago, to their ‘secret’ training methods. When those ‘secret’ methods were copied and used in other parts of the globe the results remained ordinary. More recent, ‘new wisdom’ analyses reveal that the decisive role played in the total supremacy of Kenyan and Ethiopian athletes in distance running, has been the influences of geography, altitude, climate, diet, traditional and social elements.

For millennia these factors are responsible for influencing genetic traits that warrant Kenyans and Ethiopians a specific kind of athletic superiority. Can such similarity be found in football? The cases are there to be acknowledged but we are too busy enjoying the fiasco of ‘globalised football’. Some neuroscientists would be puzzled by the stand taken in football by its ‘experts’, who insist that the principles of modern football, the game mentality and training must unconditionally apply worldwide, regardless of the conditions inherited within local or regional environment.

This baseless belief translates into cancelling some, if not all, environmental influences that could add value or innovate the game, but do not fit the pattern of globalised football. A brief look at only few such prominent influences, like the climate, altitude or geography, would confirm why environment is a powerful factor in the way we think about the game, play and construct and interpret performance. Again, to assist in getting the facts right, it is necessary to consider references from relevant studies and research. For example, it is generally known that a year-round warm or mild climate creates conditions for enjoyable and relaxed outdoor activities.

Surely, sports like football benefit directly from warm climates (an exception though is the case of vastly arid, hot and dry regions). Having the opportunity to spend a lot of time, year-round, playing and exercising with the ball, children in particular, develop excellent ball skills, coordination, agility and a strong interest for the game. The conditions are ideal to extensively use movement in general and football in particular, to enhance creativity and the entertaining features of the game.

The football mentality generated from this environment is strongly associated with skillful, fluent and in many ways, spectacular play. All these attributes may not characterisee football in Africa, South America, Asia and some regions in southern Europe if the climate would have not played its role. Also, the Latin flair largely contributes to the case. As we see it now, there are benefits that currently impact high performance and international competitions as well.

Four out of the top five Fifa-ranked nations and all five short-listed players for the 2009 Fifa World Player Award are representatives of football shaped by the influences of warm or mild climates. By contrast, it has been demonstrated, that the harshly cold winter climate in Europe and other parts of the globe, which greatly restricts enjoyable and relaxed outdoor activities to only few months a year, contribute to inducing limited flexibility, coordination and agility. In this scenario, the game approach is understandably based on more physical, direct and less creative effort.

Two different profiles of South African players

More information and understanding is also necessary to recognise the effects of altitude on the genetic traits. We are made aware that, for example, players originally from low or medium altitude environments show significant physical and psychological differences as compared to those who are genetically influenced by high altitude conditions. The strong and muscular body composition of west Africans is in contrast with the slim, light frame of east Africans and those differences are clearly identified in the different dynamics of their football.

In South Africa, it is recognised that most of the physically stronger, more skillful, more imaginative and individualistic players are coming from the low altitude of KZN. This is reflected by the fact that the youth national teams comprise over 60 per cent of players from this region. Tswana and Sotho players are characterised by light body structure and play features indicating excellent natural endurance capacity, functional technique, mobility and more determination compared with the others.

Obviously, there are other examples of ‘crossed’ influences between different population groups and regions but the focus we should not lose is the amazing work the environment does on influencing the genetic setup. The more knowledge is extracted from this processes the better chances are for the game to excel.

The movement of players, mainly from Africa and South America, to Europe and other regions has indeed led to an amalgamation of influences and mentalities but the fact that the environment exercises major influence in competitive football should never be underestimated. The full magnitude of this factor is acknowledged when other aspects of social, economic, cultural and religious significance are seriously analysed. Unfortunately, it is an area of indifferent attitude on the side of sport research and football expertise.

Learning more

If the new knowledge produced in the name of ‘new wisdom’ of neuroscience and other relevant sources is even remotely assimilated in the theory and practice of football, the way we think, train and play the game will change forever. Already football is becoming too complex for rigid, simplistic or exclusively logical theories and debates. Chris Langton, one of the world’s leading researchers in the field of complexity theory, has predicted that in the future science will become more poetic.

The meaning of it, for football, is that many new discoveries on the role and functions of the football brain are now overlapping traditional stereotypes of statistical and linear football. The new era has dawned…The time has arrived for the technicians to look at personality, mentality, passion, emotion, imagination and dedication (among others) as powerful sources of performance and further development of the game.

I support the view that the area of neuroscience is not easily accessible. Difficult technical language and scientific jargon is far more complicated than what it is written in coaching manuals. Efforts are made to simplify the difficult language and expressions of scientific terminology and replace it with easy-to-read and stimulating language.

Meanwhile, the challenge of learning more about advancements in football must be taken responsibly and promptly by all servants of the game.

The interest and dedication to access superior knowledge will always be rewarded. It is something I can guarantee.

To view Part 1 and previous other columns click on the read link below


Name: *
Email: *
City / Town: *
Comments:
*
* Required

mbaki manyake (gaborone) - Tuesday February 16 2010 - 19:03
read
Vinent Sabelo (Parktown, Jhb) - Wednesday February 10 2010 - 10:28
it is obvious that Safa's coaching syllabus is responsible for very poor standards of soccer especially at the youth level. It has to be completely revised with the latest sport science data.
I believe those coaching qualification levels whic are now in place should be declared nul and void and new coaching courses should be introduced. We are many, many years behind and radical changes are needed to correct the problem. Do it now Safa or soon it will be too late.
Victor (kempton park) - Tuesday February 09 2010 - 02:02
Ted u will always produce or recognise best players. Look at ure idea of starting academy of football in South Africa, Sport School of Excellence. Ted will you agree with me when I say the only player needed for national team is Benedict Vilakazi. Can u ask Pitso and his company to look at him because he is what we need to get goals ? When Pareira started coaching Bafana Bafana he said he will build the team around him "TSO" and he is still the same "TSO" or is because of the team he is playing for or what ? Papi Zothwane ,Tso Vilakazi and Mbulelo Mabizela can make the Spine of the team and please don't judge someone by media reports .
Tauyame (Gauteng, RSA) (JHB) - Monday February 08 2010 - 18:28
With no doubt this is a robust approach which make infinite sense. Sadly i dont think it will make any two cent worth of information to the owners and administrators of our football here in South Africa. To fully have a desired and superlative football brain requires proper development from as young as 5 years once a talent manifest itself. It's glaring that the current crop of couches locally lacks this insight, hence you notice a same player who has been playing for over 5 years in PSL repeating the same mistake. In RSA this article is ahead of it's time. To be precise 38 years ahead. Well done Ted
Steve (Polokwane) - Monday February 08 2010 - 15:20
It is a nice article well researched
Thumelane (Orlando East, Soweto) - Monday February 08 2010 - 14:33
According to an article in one of the dailly newspapers, the Sport School of Excellence has produced the best young stars in SA at the time when Ted was the technical director of the school. It make sense to say that if the school is going to become one of the best in the world, as Safa wishes, then Ted's research must lead the way. Anything less, will end up in another failure. Safa should see what is happening at Sundowns where Xulu, Siyabonga and other talented boys have reached top level performance in no time. This wisdom was totally missed in the past and we were made to pay a heavy price for not having the correct youth coaching expertise.
Jabu (Midrand) - Monday February 08 2010 - 10:10
Dr D Moroke has made a good point that generally speaking in SA football we lack the speticular football. One need to note that Ted has mentioned that development must start from under 10 and he has stated that proper development takes about 10 years. I also do not understand why the under 20/ under 17 trialists what are they trying to achieve. I also think as the mandate from the Chairman they need to conquer africa that's why they have spent a lot of many buying players. According to the info given by Ted at the age of 16 thats a player completion in terms of development and after that there is minimal impact in terms of development. for his teams to not demonstract these tracts is because they were not introduced at an early age to the players. As for bafana in 2006 one can not judge Ted about it because bafana have been declining even Peraira failed to win a game in 2008 AFCON. It just shows that development at grass root level in not happening. I mean supersport and Ajax have the influence of dutch football from development but still we have not produced top quality footballers. the specifics Ted is been highlighting are important because the dutch does not use germany manual to coach their players. Neither the english using a foreign manual they can incomporate some tracts from other countries to make their manual. What is Ted is saying we need to use our manual with our own research. Thats when Dr D Moroke comes in with his medical back ground to explain the complex of the brain and how does it function so that we can train our young players with knowledge. 95% of our youth technician do not have degree but only have coaching level 2 by safa or they trained from germany. That is not enough i mean Wenger is an economist, that why he does not go to the market to by just for the sake of buying infact he has lamented that the current economy does not allow to spend a lot of money in the market. Liverpool are in debt.
Mark (Manchester, England) - Sunday February 07 2010 - 12:10
I am not sure if the no 1 coaching publication in football called Soccer Coaching International magazine is available in South Africa. If anyone could read it (the latest issue of English edition) would find out that the same important points circulated in these columns are also hot attractions within the international coaching fraternity. The magazine give special attention to mental factor in football, i.e., the decision making , how speed affects the quality of tactical thinking and the role of technical skills in improving competitiveness and mood, etc. As a SPSC student and aspirant coach I find the information contained in Mr Dumitr's columns is reaching a step higher as it recognizes more practical aspects (mainly in the development of young players). I think his work is ahead of time and by some distance.
Lawrence Phiri (Ndola, Zambia) - Saturday February 06 2010 - 14:32
The tips and information in general is greatly appreciated by my coaches and pupils in our academy. Please Teddy give us more ammunition especially for improving technique and attitude. Many thanks to the provider.
Siya (Vosloorus) - Friday February 05 2010 - 08:09
Hi Ted

If Ted is so good in football why did you fail the the country in 2006 when he was given a chance.We did not score a single goal under Ted. Zambias only win was agains S.A.
So Lucky think about someone else not the proven looser in the squad.
DR D Moroke (Klerksdorp) - Thursday February 04 2010 - 16:05
I want to put it on record that I agreed with this particular column by Ted. I openly disagreed with him in the past columns.

A week ago I went to see what is happening at SUNDOWNS/PUK-TAWANA training sessions. I saw nothing close to what Ted is writng about. There were two groups, u/20 and u/17(trialists). Both sets of players look older than their age categories! They should be in PSL. Looking on I could not deduce what the sessions were about. It was not inspirational at all.

Last weekend I attended their home game. The team was technically poor, tactically bankrupt with poor athletism and lacking in mental determination. I did not see any signs of the "football brain"! The defenders kept passing the ball from side to side until one of them would try a desperate long ball that mostly ended up with the opponents.They had four lame strikes at goals in the whole match! They lost the game 0-1 to University of Northwest Mafikeng Campus.

My conclusion is that people who think Sundows development is going to bring us players that can play spectacular football, they must forget!What Ted writes about is only in his mind and is not reflected at that development team!

When Ted was still an "active coach", I was always struck by the contrast between his interviews and the way the teams he coached played. It still continues!

Luckily, this team has qualified for NEDBANK CUP, you be the judge!
Lucky (Gauteng) - Thursday February 04 2010 - 14:20
Hi Ted

I am student of sport in general and a teacher by profession. I always find your coloumns to be very insightful and your understanding of the football is very useful to all the sport fanatics.

Why cant SAFA employ you to assist the national team coaches in whatever capacity where your knowledge will benefit the national team since the we are the host nation?

Keep up the good work and I will alwaya read your coloumns. Feel free to drop me an e-mail whenever you can, I will apppreciate that very much.

Have a nice day.

From

Lucky.
dav (Kzn) - Thursday February 04 2010 - 11:32
Nice Article Mr Dumitri , I think this is relevant to SA Football . I have coached at youth level and noticed the need for effective coaching. Why arent their more coaching courses in Sa. In Uk or any where else you can do a course or whatever. A basic level course . Theres alot of potential . I think the black players especially will benefit from this type of coaching
Nkululeko Mfecane (Cape Town) - Wednesday February 03 2010 - 12:32
Innocent, this is the new South Africa you can use whatever language and word you want to as you also did in your article, if you are not happy about my wording, well there is nothing I can do, take me to HRC if you like. Its good to hear that an ex professional footballer has made it big in business and I trust that you have followed the proper procedures not the short route of "tenderproneurs"that seems to dominate political headlines,seeing that you are from Soweto I will not be suprised. To all the sober minded football lovers and players I didn't mean to offend you in any way, the school doors are still open. Keep the passion
Innocent Dlamini (Orlando East, Soweto) - Tuesday February 02 2010 - 18:15
I am an ex-professional player (still kicking the ball, occasionally) and successful business man and for an idiot like Mfecane to call us 'brainless individuals' it is revolting! This so-called 'intellectual' is nothing but an impostor. A man of science won't call footballers 'brainless individuals'. As for the article, by just reading it is a delightful experience. Thank you Ted || Supersoprt
Jabu (Midrand) - Tuesday February 02 2010 - 17:01
It is always wonderful to read Ted's articles because they are informative. It is important to note that to label football players as brainless is not a right language to use. Surely a new era has don
NKULULEKO MFECANE (Cape Town) - Tuesday February 02 2010 - 15:06
Rodney, I have absolutely nothing personal against Ted, I valued the kind of input he is providing you as young and upcoming coaches, I even went on to highlight his input on his findings on the research based on Italian and Spanish football players and how they play, unfortunately I am not
a football coach and I have no aspirations of becoming one, I know exactly what Ted is talking about, as for the Afcon results during while he was at helm, well the record is there for everyone to see, you know Rodney unlike you,I was priviledged enough to achieve so much with my studies and I'm not relying on brainless individuals who happens to chase the ball around to provide for their families, all I was saying was that I hope this theory can
be translated into action if we want to reap the rewards. Once again I have got nothing personal against Ted and I'm sure he is not worried at all about my input judging by his intellectual standard
Joe Maluleke (Johannesburg) - Tuesday February 02 2010 - 11:59
Hi Mark (Manchester) please send me an email at info@supersoccer.co.za and I will get back to you.
Mark (Manchester, ENGLAND) - Friday January 29 2010 - 09:35
Please assist, if possible, with Mr. Ted Dumitru contacts.
Rodney (Bosmont) - Thursday January 28 2010 - 10:50
Mfecane, let's make sure that personal agendas are not used to degrade the merits of these columns. Any honest reader would realise that the information provided here is based on positive practical results as well as new research. What "publicity" and "personal gain" would Mr. Dumitru seek from his writing when he has achieved so much. Some of us, as youth coaches, continue to gain a lot from these articles. Malicious attempts to undermine such contributions must stop! Do not pretend that you know what Mr. Dumitru is talking about because you don't. The blunders made by Safa at the 2006 afcon campaign completely destroyed the morale of the team and Mr. Dumitru can not be blamed for that. Before the Safa' sabotage, Bafana Bafana managed to beat Egypt and was showing signs of greatness. Shamefully, we failed the coach. In fact, I tend to agree with another comment which says that we in SA may not deserve Mr. Dumitru.
Nkululeko Mfecane (Cape Town) - Wednesday January 27 2010 - 14:24
Ted, I hope you are doing this with Sundowms, I hope this research is not seeking publicity as an expert but as someone who is sincerely interested in developing our young raw football talent in this coutry not for personnal gain, you have failed us before with your football brain (during your tenure as Bafana Coach) I know you have made some excellent obervation with Spanish ||Italian football (remeber your article with M||G),I will have to wait and see and make my conclusion and I gues it will be in 5 years time hoping that you will still be alive. By the way I have studies Sport Exercise Science and I know exaclty what are you talking about but I am more interested in the application part of it as you know the demands of our professional teams either at junior or at senior leve (the emphasis is on winning)
DR D MOROKE (KLERKSDORP) - Wednesday January 27 2010 - 11:46
Aaron click on All Columns below the article to get part 1.
Mokola (Lusaka, Zambia) - Wednesday January 27 2010 - 09:28
My beloved Africa, open your eyes and conquer ignorance for the sake of our beautiful football!!
Aaron Nyangkwe (Douala) - Tuesday January 26 2010 - 21:45
Extremely educative piece! Many thanks Doctor.
I am still new on this site and did not get part one.

Whjere is it? For God's sake!
Simon (Parktown, Jhb) - Tuesday January 26 2010 - 14:14
This is fabulous material but do not expect safa to react or act positively. Those soccer illiterates, idiotically, can hire a German to teach our coaches German soccer while the same lunitics appoint a Brazilian to coach Bafana Bafana!!??? I just hope Ted will next address the issue of shortage of football brain (or any brain) among our administrators.

Recent Blogs
Argentina seek Spanish identity
Free State Stars to test Pirates
On form Sundowns face tricky Stars
Cup semifinalists Birds, Ajax square up
Adokiye Amiesimaka
Can new 'NFF' board fulfil our dream?
I do not have any sympathy for those who participated in...
Jos Dirkx
High performance praise for Bantwana
Sitting proudly in her uniform, Ms Fran Hilton-Smith...
Ted Dumitru
The aftermath...
'If a man is proud of his wealth, he should not be praised...
Thomas Kwenaite
Why do we pretend match fixing does not exist?
The evidence coming out of the Semenya Commission of...
 
 
 
What do you think of Bafana Bafana’s performance in their 2-0 win against Niger?
Great display
Average
Just fine